The Setup Heading Into May
A read-through of one trading desk’s metals and energy positioning — and what it tells long-term investors about where the asymmetry sits
This article synthesizes commentary from the published weekly market briefings of a third-party trading service. CI Mavericks does not transact in short-term futures or CFD positions at the SPC level — our metals and energy exposure is held through long-duration physical and equity positions.
Natural Gas: A Setup the Desk Calls Asymmetric
Of the markets the desk is currently watching, natural gas is the one they describe as offering the most favorable risk-reward profile. Four converging signals: seasonality (90% historical rate of upside mid-April through May-June), positioning (commercial positions near decade longs, CTAs maximally short), technical structure (falling-wedge breakout reclaiming weekly and monthly pivots), and sentiment (extreme fear readings by historical standards).
When commercial hedgers are positioned near multi-year long extremes and trend-following systematic funds are near short extremes, the mathematical room for the contract to fall meaningfully further is constrained. That asymmetry exists independent of any view on the desk’s specific technical work.
Gold: From Accumulation to Distribution
Following the largest single-month gold correction in 40 years — a March move to roughly $4,100 — the desk built positions during the dislocation and is now in distribution mode against the rally back toward $4,900. Their seasonal framework anticipates that gold may set up a deeper pullback into May and June, which they would treat as a re-entry opportunity rather than a directional reversal.
This differs from our posture. CI Mavericks holds physical gold as a long-duration store-of-value position, contributed as JV capital. We do not distribute on technical strength and do not re-enter on technical weakness. Both approaches can be correct simultaneously, because they are answering different questions.
Silver and Crude: Pattern Parity, Circumspection
Silver topped at roughly $120, corrected sharply to $63, and currently trades around $80 — a chart that rhymes closely with crude oil’s Q1 trajectory. On crude, the desk is most circumspect: trading below key moving averages, down more than 30% from the Q1 high, and currently trading more on news flow and political signaling than fundamentals. The desk’s decision to step back from active oil positioning until the regime changes is the disciplined response.
The Stamina Game: How the Small Trader Gets Shaken Out
Embedded in the desk’s commentary is a recurring observation about how price action behaves around important technical levels. Large players repeatedly run price into and through obvious stop-loss zones before the genuine breakout occurs. Each pass takes out a fresh wave of small traders.
“It’s a stamina game. By the time it gets to Friday, most traders that had the position on are tired out. They’ve been in and out of this market three times already in the week. They leave it, move on to another market — and that’s where you have the massive breakout.”
For long-duration investors, the practical implication is straightforward. The thesis can be correct and the price action can still produce three or four convincing-looking invalidations along the way. The most reliable way to avoid being on the wrong side of the stamina game is, simply, not to need stamina in the first place. Hold positions whose conviction does not depend on a weekly chart.
The CI Mavericks Read
The desk’s current read — constructive on natural gas into a potential short squeeze, distributing gold at strength, stepping back from crude until the regime changes — collectively describes a market in which the easy directional trades of Q1 (long gold, long oil) are now harder to underwrite, and the better-positioned trades require more patience.
For members holding metals and energy exposure through CI Mavericks structures, none of this changes the long-term thesis. Physical gold remains a structural store-of-value position. Natural gas and Argentine energy remain core long-duration themes anchored to real assets and real cash flows, not to weekly contract pricing.
“We didn’t panic. We didn’t sell. We invest for the long term.” That principle does not exempt us from paying attention to short-term positioning. It governs how we use what we see.
Published for informational and educational purposes only. This article does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice, and does not constitute a recommendation to purchase, hold, or dispose of any security or commodity.